Skip to main content

Highly Qualified But Still Not Trusted


The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 required schools to hire "highly qualified" teachers, which works out to mean that grade school ESL teachers need to have the same educational and experience qualifications as medical doctors.  Doctors can diagnose, yet, for some reason, State and local level administrators can't allow teachers to be the judges of their students' progress.  The only data acceptable to the State are from the State's standardized tests.  Why not allow teachers to submit data from formative classroom assessments?  I think the Home Language Questionnaire  and initial exams to determine student language stages are important, especially when use in conjunction with oral examination and interviews by highly qualified ESL teachers.  However, after that the judgment of an ELL's language performance becomes more subtle and subjective.  How a student is progressing in learning language is best judged by the teacher's in-class observations (Tracy, 2009).  There are sociocultural elements that can't be demonstrated on paper.  There are strategic competencies that can't be demonstrated on paper.  Yet these are skills that allow a person to communicate and survive in the workaday world.  If the goal of education is to prepare students for college and career success, then there's more to it than passing a standardized test.  The focus of learning should never be on the test, and in fact, that was not the original intent of the legislation (Baron, 2014).  That just seems to be the way it has come to be interpreted.  

References
Baron, K. (2014). NCLB co-author says he never anticipated federal law would force testing obsession. Retrieved March 21, 2018, from https://edsource.org/2014/rep-miller-says-he-never-anticipated-nclb-would-force-testing-obsession/56665

 Tracy, A. M. (2009). Analysis of ESL teacher endorsement effects on English language learners' student achievement and English language acquisition (Order No. 3491679). Available from Education Database. (915645020). Retrieved from http://ezproxy.ace.edu/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Schoolhouse Rock and Musical Intelligence

I do not intend to turn this blog into a running obituary, but I believe it is important to mention that Bob Dorough passed away on April 24th, 2018.  He was 94 years old.  He was one of the creators of the Schoolhouse Rock animated musical series that ran during the period from 1973-1985.  They were created to help children learn and remember content they needed in their school classes. I can still sing many of these tunes I heard on TV when I was a child. There are many studies surrounding the Multiple Intelligences Theory of Howard Gardner ( Brualdi, 1998).  Gardner examines seven intelligences which he defines as   "the capacity to solve problems or to fashion products that are valued in one or more cultural settings" ( Gardner  & Hatch, 1989).  One of the seven is musical intelligence.  People may possess and use forms of these intelligences in various mixtures with individuals having greater abilities in some areas than others....
Post a Comment
Read more

Human Research Ethics and Teacher/Student Relationships

As part of my Masters in Education program at American College of Education , I recently took a course in ethics related to using humans as research subjects .  This course was through the National Institutes of Health and led to a certification.  Some of my peers questioned why it would be necessary for teachers to be concerned about how to treat human subjects in research.  However, when you think about it, we are constantly observing our students, gathering data, experimenting with our methods and planning, and making adjustments based on student feedback.  We often share our observations about our students with our peers and with students' parents.  We also guide our students' use of and access to outside information.  This could be considered study of human subjects, and as such has certain ethical ramifications. The three basic ethical principles that came from the Belmont Report  are: Respect for persons , which involves informed consent; Benef...
Post a Comment
Read more

"Why the Best Teachers Don't Give Tests"

I stole the title for this post directly from a 2014 blog post by Alfie Kohn (  https://www.alfiekohn.org/blogs/no-tests/  ), who is a writer of many books and articles about education.  I was alerted to his website by my Twitter connection to Dr. Stephen Krashen (@skrashen), the well-known explorer of language acquisition theory.  Both of their accounts are worth following because they frequently post links to great resources for educators.  This particular article touches on a theme that remains a hot topic in educational discussions, and I'm pretty sure we haven't solved the issues it raises. There are a couple of comments I would like to make in response to his article.  The first is that I generally agree with his point that there are many effective ways to judge student progress that are not formal tests.  I wish I had known more about some of these when I was teaching English in Brazil.  I know for a fact that I was unable to pass certain...
Post a Comment
Read more