Skip to main content

Highly Qualified But Still Not Trusted


The No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 required schools to hire "highly qualified" teachers, which works out to mean that grade school ESL teachers need to have the same educational and experience qualifications as medical doctors.  Doctors can diagnose, yet, for some reason, State and local level administrators can't allow teachers to be the judges of their students' progress.  The only data acceptable to the State are from the State's standardized tests.  Why not allow teachers to submit data from formative classroom assessments?  I think the Home Language Questionnaire  and initial exams to determine student language stages are important, especially when use in conjunction with oral examination and interviews by highly qualified ESL teachers.  However, after that the judgment of an ELL's language performance becomes more subtle and subjective.  How a student is progressing in learning language is best judged by the teacher's in-class observations (Tracy, 2009).  There are sociocultural elements that can't be demonstrated on paper.  There are strategic competencies that can't be demonstrated on paper.  Yet these are skills that allow a person to communicate and survive in the workaday world.  If the goal of education is to prepare students for college and career success, then there's more to it than passing a standardized test.  The focus of learning should never be on the test, and in fact, that was not the original intent of the legislation (Baron, 2014).  That just seems to be the way it has come to be interpreted.  

References
Baron, K. (2014). NCLB co-author says he never anticipated federal law would force testing obsession. Retrieved March 21, 2018, from https://edsource.org/2014/rep-miller-says-he-never-anticipated-nclb-would-force-testing-obsession/56665

 Tracy, A. M. (2009). Analysis of ESL teacher endorsement effects on English language learners' student achievement and English language acquisition (Order No. 3491679). Available from Education Database. (915645020). Retrieved from http://ezproxy.ace.edu/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Internet Power Sites for English Language Learners

Here are a few major websites that I highly recommend because they offer extensive resources for English Language teachers and learners alike. The BBC World Service   has been around for a long time, but recently moved its link, so here is the latest one http://www.bbc.co.uk/learningenglish/ This site has courses, games, videos, and practice for every level of EAL.  VOA Learning English   is the go-to site for American English.  It also has news in easy to listen to English, and insights into North American culture.  I like the variety of  videos on every subject you could think of.  There should be something here to interest anyone. https://learningenglish.voanews.com/ The United States Department of State has several sites dedicated to teaching and learning English. The links can all be found here:   https://americanenglish.state.gov/ PBS Learning is not focused specifically on English Language Learners, but it has teaching a...
Post a Comment
Read more

In Memoriam of First Lady Barbara Bush 1925-2018

Literacy is an important issue for ESL teachers.  I was saddened to hear that Barbara Bush passed away  yesterday.   Barbara Bush was a champion for  literacy .   She was responsible for helping to pass the  National Literacy Act of 1991.  She started a  foundation to promote literacy which you can access here.   I met her personally during a fund raiser at a Women's literacy club in Naples Florida. I was a news cameraman covering the event..  When it came time for our interview she leaned over to me and asked, "May I give you some advice in a motherly way?"  "Sure, of course!" I replied.  " You had  better close the barn door before the horse gets out."  I had forgotten to zip up my pants. - Dan
Post a Comment
Read more

Appropriateness

My wife, who was born in Brazil, follows a number of online social media ESL teachers.  At this time I am not one of them.  However, she often comes to me with questions because she is confused about what the teachers are putting out there. It seems to very popular to discuss unusual expressions or idioms without including appropriate contexts.  I believe that language should not be taught without teaching appropriate, contextual usage at the same time. This also applies to teaching the rules and skills of native language to native language speakers.  Wheeler & Swords (2004)  made some interesting observations about how this can work in a classroom when trying to teach students with varied home languages to speak in a more formal way in the classroom.  Students are able to begin code switching - changing their language usage to a different variety - when they understand that there may be a difference in the variety of English that is appropriate for the...
Post a Comment
Read more